Einzelposting: Titel von Buch 7 beckannt gegeben (Spoiler)

Von:    Lothiril 04.07.2007 15:04 Betreff: Titel von Buch 7 beckannt gegeben (Spoil... [Antworten]
Hm, ich nehme mir mal die Frechheit und äußere mich zu dem Thema "Was macht Slytherin noch an Hogwarts": Also warum die Slytherins nicht einfach rausgeschmissen werden: Ich hab dazu in nem Buch zu HP-Hintergrundinfos was gelesen, was ich als Erklärung angemessen finde... :) Ich tipp es mal ab; ist allerdings in englisch (und ich bin für ne Übersetzung zu faul >>): "Given how agreeable the school can be, one has to wonder what the Slytherins are doing there. Every bit of trouble seems to start with a Slytherin. There doesen't seem to be a decent student in that house. Its philosophy seems to be the same dark thought expressed by Quirrell in Rowling's ~Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone~: 'There is no good and evil, there is only power, and those too weak to seek it.' Salazar Slytherin, the Hogwarts founder for whom the house was named, was so devious he even built the Chamber of Secrets under the school without telling the other founders. So wouldn't it make sense to just get rid of them? Actually, that would seem to be the opposite of J.K. Rowling's philosophy. In fact, the presence of Slytherin at Hogwarts seems to say a lot about her ideas of good and evil. Within the walls of Hogwarts, Dumbledore's leadershio has created an appealing ideal. Evil is not pushed away fearfully; or simply met with courageous force. It is to be countered with compassion. More than once, Dumbledore has demonstrated a strong faith taht fallen wizards can redeem themselves. Each of the four founders of Hogwarts had individual qualities that form part of a balanced whole. Even Slytherin's ambition can be directed towards good - provided it is balanced with the characteristics displayed by the others. it is part of realitiy, part of every individual - just as Harry has a bit of Voldemort in him. Trying to eliminate it would be silly, as well as impossible." Dazu ergänzend: Was würde passieren, wenn man alle, die der Hut für Slytherin auswählt, rausschmeißen würde? Sie würden vllt zu Durmstrang gehen, und da würde es dann eine größere Ansammlung von "Bösen" geben... Und da sie ja eigentlich nichts getan haben, kann man sie sowieso nicht rausschmeißen... Also ist es so ziemlich die einzige, vernünftige Lösung... oô The power of art is the power to create.